Question | Is it true? Is it true

Attention! Some of this material is not in the public domain.

It is illegal to copy and distribute our copyright-protected material without permission. It is also illegal to reprint copyright texts or translations without the name of the author or translator.

To inquire about permissions and rates, contact Emily Ezust at licenses@email.lieder.example.net

If you wish to reprint translations, please make sure you include the names of the translators in your email. They are below each translation.

Note: You must use the copyright symbol © when you reprint copyright-protected material.

sometimes misattributed to Johann Heinrich Voss (1751 - 1826) and by Felix Mendelssohn (1809 - 1847)

Translation © by Emily Ezust

Frage

Language: German (Deutsch)

Our translations: CAT DUT ENG FRE

Ist es wahr? Ist es wahr?
Daß du stets dort in dem Laubgang,
An der Weinwand meiner harrst?
Und den Mondschein und die Sternlein
Auch nach mir befragst?

Ist es wahr? Sprich!
Was ich fühle, das begreift nur,
Die es mit fühlt,
Und die treu mir ewig,
Treu mir ewig, ewig bleibt.

Note: The first edition of opus 9 attributed the text to "H. Voss", but Sebastian Hensel (Fanny's son) later wrote that Felix Mendelssohn wrote both music and words on June 6, 1827. Source : Mendelssohn - 24 Songs : Medium Voice, ed. John Glenn Paton, Alfred Music Publishing, 1992.

Text Authorship:

sometimes misattributed to Johann Heinrich Voss (1751 - 1826)
by Felix Mendelssohn (1809 - 1847) [author's text checked 1 time against a primary source]

Musical settings (art songs, Lieder, mélodies, (etc.), choral pieces, and other vocal works set to this text), listed by composer (not necessarily exhaustive):

by Max Lippold (1845 - 1910), "Frage", op. 20 (Vier Lieder für 1 Singstimme mit Pianoforte) no. 2, published 1892 [ voice and piano ], Hamburg, Rahter [sung text not yet checked]
by Felix Mendelssohn (1809 - 1847), "Frage", op. 9 (Zwölf Lieder [nos. 7, 10, and 12 are by Fanny Mendelssohn-Hensel]) no. 1 [sung text checked 1 time]

Available translations, adaptations or excerpts, and transliterations (if applicable):

CAT Catalan (Català) (Salvador Pila) , "Pregunta", copyright © 2022, (re)printed on this website with kind permission
DUT Dutch (Nederlands) [singable] (Lau Kanen) , "Vraag", copyright © 2016, (re)printed on this website with kind permission
ENG English (Emily Ezust) , "Question", copyright ©
FRE French (Français) (Guy Laffaille) , "Question", copyright © 2010, (re)printed on this website with kind permission

Researcher for this text: Emily Ezust [Administrator]

This text was added to the website between May 1995 and September 2003.
Line count: 10
Word count: 52

Question

Language: English after the German (Deutsch)

Is it true? Is it true
that over there in the leafy walkway, you always
wait for me by the vine-draped wall?
And that with the moonlight and the little stars
you consult about me also?

Is it true? Speak!
What I feel, only she grasps --
she who feels with me
and stays ever faithful to me,
eternally faithful.

Text Authorship:

Translation from German (Deutsch) to English copyright © by Emily Ezust
Emily Ezust permits her translations to be reproduced without prior permission for printed (not online) programs to free-admission concerts only, provided the following credit is given:
Translation copyright © by Emily Ezust,
from the LiederNet Archive
For any other purpose, please write to the e-mail address below to request permission and discuss possible fees.
licenses@email.lieder.example.net

Based on:

a text in German (Deutsch) misattributed to Johann Heinrich Voss (1751 - 1826) and by Felix Mendelssohn (1809 - 1847)
- Go to the text page.

This text was added to the website between May 1995 and September 2003.
Line count: 10
Word count: 59