LiederNet logo

CONTENTS

×
  • Home | Introduction
  • Composers (20,107)
  • Text Authors (19,481)
  • Go to a Random Text
  • What’s New
  • A Small Tour
  • FAQ & Links
  • Donors
  • DONATE

UTILITIES

  • Search Everything
  • Search by Surname
  • Search by Title or First Line
  • Search by Year
  • Search by Collection

CREDITS

  • Emily Ezust
  • Contributors (1,114)
  • Contact Information
  • Bibliography

  • Copyright Statement
  • Privacy Policy

Follow us on Facebook

×

Attention! Some of this material is not in the public domain.

It is illegal to copy and distribute our copyright-protected material without permission. It is also illegal to reprint copyright texts or translations without the name of the author or translator.

To inquire about permissions and rates, contact Emily Ezust at licenses@email.lieder.example.net

If you wish to reprint translations, please make sure you include the names of the translators in your email. They are below each translation.

Note: You must use the copyright symbol © when you reprint copyright-protected material.

by Paul Heyse (1830 - 1914)
Translation © by Emily Ezust

Soll ich ihn lieben
Language: German (Deutsch) 
Our translations:  ENG FRE
Soll ich ihn lieben, 
Soll ich ihn [hassen]1,
Dem sich mein Herz schon heimlich ergab?
Soll ich mich üben,
Recht ihn zu hassen?
Rate mir gut, doch rate nicht ab!

Wild ist er freilich, 
Heftig von Sitten,
Keiner begreift es, wie lieb ich ihn hab'.
Aber so heilig 
Kann er auch bitten --
Rate mir gut, doch rate nicht ab!

Reichere könnt' ich, 
Weisere haben;
Gut ist im Leben ein sicher Stab.
Keiner doch gönnt' ich 
Den wilden Knaben --
Rate mir gut, doch rate nicht ab!

Laß ich von schlimmer 
Wahl mich betören,
Besser, ich legte mich gleich ins Grab.
Klug ist es immer, 
Auf Rat zu hören --
Rate mir gut, doch rate nicht ab!

Available sung texts: (what is this?)

•   A. Fielitz 

About the headline (FAQ)

View original text (without footnotes)
1 Fielitz: "lassen"

Text Authorship:

  • by Paul Heyse (1830 - 1914), no title, appears in Skizzenbuch. Lieder und Bilder, in Mädchenlieder, no. 1 [author's text checked 1 time against a primary source]

Musical settings (art songs, Lieder, mélodies, (etc.), choral pieces, and other vocal works set to this text), listed by composer (not necessarily exhaustive):

  • by Alexander von Fielitz (1860 - 1930), "Soll ich ihn lieben", op. 40 no. 7, published 1895 [ high voice and piano ], from Acht Mädchenlieder von Paul Heyse, no. 7, Leipzig, Breitkopf & Härtel [sung text checked 1 time]
  • by Hans Huber (1852 - 1921), "Soll ich ihn lieben", op. 61 no. 6, published 1881 [ high voice and piano ], from Mädchenlieder, no. 6, Zürich, Hug [sung text not yet checked]
  • by D. Melamet , "Mädchenfrage", op. 2 (Vier Lieder für Sopran mit Pianoforte) no. 3, published 1891 [ soprano and piano ], Berlin, Luckhardt [sung text not yet checked]
  • by Erik Meyer-Helmund (1861 - 1932), "Guter Rath", op. 19 (Drei Lieder für 1 Singstimme mit Pianoforte) no. 3, published 1886 [ voice and piano ], Berlin, Ries & Erler [sung text not yet checked]
  • by Georg Schumann (1866 - 1952), "Soll ich ihn lieben?", op. 35 no. 5, published 1904 [ voice and piano ], from Mädchenlieder für Gesang und Klavier, no. 5, Leipzig, F. E. C. Leuckart [sung text not yet checked]
  • by Felix Semon, M. D. (1849 - 1921), "Soll ich ihn lieben", op. 7 (Sieben Lieder für 1 mittlere Stimme mit Pianoforte) no. 4, published 1881 [ medium voice and piano ], Berlin, Bote & Bock [sung text not yet checked]
  • by Benno Stolzenberg (1827 - 1908), "Soll ich ihn lieben", op. 18 (Fünf Lieder für Sopran mit Pianoforte) no. 2, published 1884 [ soprano and piano ], Berlin, Schlesinger [sung text not yet checked]

Available translations, adaptations or excerpts, and transliterations (if applicable):

  • ENG English (Emily Ezust) , "Should I love him or should I leave him", copyright ©
  • FRE French (Français) (Pierre Mathé) , copyright © 2021, (re)printed on this website with kind permission


Researcher for this text: Emily Ezust [Administrator]

This text was added to the website between May 1995 and September 2003.
Line count: 24
Word count: 116

Should I love him or should I leave him
Language: English  after the German (Deutsch) 
Should I love him 
or should I leave him,
he to whom my heart has already secretly yielded?
Should I teach myself 
to hate him deeply?
Advise me well but do not dissuade me!

To be sure he is wild
and short-tempered in manner -
no one can understand how I can like him so well.
But so saintly he can be 
when he begs!
Advise me well but do not dissuade me!

I could have a man more wealthy, 
or more intelligent;
it is good in life to have a reliable staff.
But I will not give up 
my wild boy to anyone...
Advise me well but do not dissuade me!

If I let myself remain infatuated 
with a bad selection,
it would be better if I simply laid myself in the grave.
It is always intelligent 
to heed advice...
Advise me well but do not dissuade me!

Text Authorship:

  • Translation from German (Deutsch) to English copyright © by Emily Ezust

    Emily Ezust permits her translations to be reproduced without prior permission for printed (not online) programs to free-admission concerts only, provided the following credit is given:

    Translation copyright © by Emily Ezust,
    from the LiederNet Archive

    For any other purpose, please write to the e-mail address below to request permission and discuss possible fees.
    licenses@email.lieder.example.net

Based on:

  • a text in German (Deutsch) by Paul Heyse (1830 - 1914), no title, appears in Skizzenbuch. Lieder und Bilder, in Mädchenlieder, no. 1
    • Go to the text page.

 

This text was added to the website between May 1995 and September 2003.
Line count: 24
Word count: 148

Gentle Reminder

This website began in 1995 as a personal project by Emily Ezust, who has been working on it full-time without a salary since 2008. Our research has never had any government or institutional funding, so if you found the information here useful, please consider making a donation. Your help is greatly appreciated!
–Emily Ezust, Founder

Donate

We use cookies for internal analytics and to earn much-needed advertising revenue. (Did you know you can help support us by turning off ad-blockers?) To learn more, see our Privacy Policy. To learn how to opt out of cookies, please visit this site.

I acknowledge the use of cookies

Contact
Copyright
Privacy

Copyright © 2025 The LiederNet Archive

Site redesign by Shawn Thuris